|
| |

Dave Kessler's Yanagisawa Saxophone FAQ Page
What's the difference between the 901 and
the 991 series Yanagisawa saxophones? What is the
difference when using the Bronze or Silver? Is the 901
an Intermediate or a Professional model? What's the
difference between the S901 and S991 (and S981) straight sopranos?
What's the difference between the SC901 and SC991 curved
sopranos? Why have I not heard of Yanagisawa before?
|
Q: What is the
difference between the 901 and the 991 series Yanagisawa saxophones?
A: This is a question that we get asked a lot.
While there are several differences on the 901 vs the 991, it is
important to note that they are built around the same fundamental
design. In fact, on the alto, tenor & bari sax (this issue does not
apply to the soprano), if you take just the bare tube parts of the horn
(neck, body, bow & bell) without any keys or key posts on them, these
are actually the same part on the 901 & 991.
The principle difference is the construction style of
the key posts to the body. With the A/T/B 901, each post is individually
soldered on to the body. On the A/T/B 991, large groups of posts are
first attached to a large brass "rib" and then that entire rib is
attached to the body. This "ribbed construction" places more metal on to
the body tube thus increasing the mass of the tube. This extra mass
produces a darker tone.
The Alto & Tenor 991 models also change the
orientation of the octave key on the neck. The A/T 901 uses a standard
top mount octave key whereas the A/T 991 uses an underslung mechanism.
Most would think this is merely a cosmetic/technical improvement. The
reality is that the braces used on the underslung design change the
weight distribution on the neck and change the overall weight. The neck
itself is the most sensitive to weight/mass changes and so the increase
of weight on the 991 series neck also gives a warmer tone.
Please note that on the soprano models, both the
S901 and S991 use ribbed construction. The difference between the S901
and the S991 is that the S901 is a 1 piece body with range to high F#
and the S991 is a dual neck model with range to high G.
Another change that we find throughout the line is
the pads. While both series of pads are of an exceptional, the 991
series uses a noticeably nicer pad.
There are other changes in the 901 vs 991 design on
the alto, tenor & bari as well, however they are not as much of a
performance difference rather than a technical improvement. Some of
these features include double arm construction of the low B & C keys &
C#-B connected roller. These features while nice, are not going to
change the performance of the saxophone.
|
|
Q: What is the
difference when using Bronze or Solid Silver?
A: The various metals used in a sax
fundamentally change the acoustic principles of the instrument. Most
will find that Bronze and Sterling Silver will add warmth and darkness
to the tonal character of the sax. Both Bronze and Sterling Silver
(92.5% pure silver) are heavier than standard brass. This extra weight
is the reason behind the warmer/darker tone. However, it is really a
personal preference as it is not always "better".
The downside to Bronze for some people is that they
find that the sax does not seem to "respond" as easily as with Brass.
Sterling Silver seems to respond as easily as (if not easier than)
brass, but still gives the warmer tone. However, Silver is more
expensive as a material and more delicate to manufacture with.
In some models, Yanagisawa mixes the various setups
of metals for various tonal and response reasons. For instance, the
A9933 is one of our favorite models that Yanagisawa makes. It features
the neck and bell tubes made from Sterling Silver with the body and the
bow still made from brass. There is even a model that is not promoted
much called the A9932 that uses the same silver neck and bell but uses
bronze on the body and bow instead of brass. Neither is definitively
better than the other, just different. The model with the bronze tubes
plays with a darker tone in comparison.
The downside to these materials is weight. Both are
heavier than brass. So especially when you go to the heavier
construction of the 99x series with one of these materials throughout
the whole horn, the weight change can be a negative aspect to them.
|
|
Q: Is the 901 series
an Intermediate or Professional model?
A: This is a loaded question to begin with. The
first thing to consider is what do those terms really mean? Sadly, these
days it seems that the industry uses those words in many cases not as a
true indicator of quality but rather as a justification of the price.
Also keep in mind that the term "professional" is misleading. There
really is no such thing as a "professional" sax, only professional
players.
However, in keeping in the spirit of the question,
really the 901 is no less of a horn than the 991. As I answered in the
first question, the difference in the 2 has to do with the weight of the
construction. Both are handmade and both use the same tubes. The
difference is that the 901 is brighter than the 991 (excludes soprano,
see the first question above).
I too have seen other websites that will list the 901
as an "Intermediate" model. A lot of this has to do with the previous
distributor in the USA's dealer materials. Many years ago, the
distributor listed the 901 series as "Intermediate" and the 991 series
as "Professional" in order to explain the price difference to dealers.
This really did an injustice to the 901 reputation in my opinion. Many
retailers have never updated this in their own databases and catalogs.
|
|
Q: Difference in
the S901 vs S991 (and S981) Sopranos?
A: The Yanagisawa soprano models do not share
the same differences as the alto/tenor/bari counterparts do. Unlike the
A/T/B 901, the S901 (straight) is actually built with the same ribbed
construction and the same advanced features of the 991 series
instruments. So tonally, the S901 and S991 (as well as the less known
S981 model) are identical.
The difference is neck & range.
S901: Solid One Piece Body, Range to High F# S981:
Dual Neck Design, Range to High F# S991: Dual Neck Design, Range to
High G
Every other aspect of the design is the same. The
S901 does feature less engraving than the others.
|
|
Q: Difference
in the SC901 vs SC991 Curved Sopranos?
A: Unlike the rest of the Yanagisawa line,
Yanagisawa does not manufacture both the SC901 and SC991 simultaneously.
The SC991 is the model made today and is the successor to the SC901.
The SC991 has 2 distinct changes in the design
compared to the SC901. The biggest is the fact that the SC901 had the
bell keys on the left side of the bell (like many vintage altos and
tenors) and the SC991 was designed to position the bell keys on the
right side of the bell like modern models. Yanagisawa did have to shift
the bell further to the left in order to accommodate the new key
position. This change was made so that they could update the left hand
pinky cluster to the modern design used throughout the rest of the 991
series lineup.
The other change that we noticed was in the angle of
the neck. Yanagisawa increased the neck angle on the SC991. This allows
the horn to be held closer to the body in a more natural alto sax
position. It also gives the saxophone a little darker tone.
|
|
Q: Why have I not
heard of Yanagisawa before?
A: Yanagisawa only makes professional
saxophones and mouthpieces. They don't make student models, other
instruments, or lawnmowers. They specialize in professional saxophones
as it is their passion. So until you are in the world of professional
saxophones, it is not uncommon to not have heard of Yanagisawa. However,
they are commonly discussed as part of the "Big 4" of professional sax
makers. The "Big 4" consists of Selmer Paris, Keilwerth (Germany),
Yanagisawa & Yamaha.
|
If you have any other questions not listed here, please feel
free to give Dave Kessler a call or send an email to
music@kesslermusic.com
|